Skip to content
HearingTracker
Log in

Resound Omnia vs Phonak Lumity

This topic is closed.

644 replies38.9k viewsLast reply

Jump
Link to this topic

In reply to @JordanK

No I haven’t, I might get around to testing at a later date, I test out all relevant platform releases from the major manufacturer’s every year, i can tell there will be be no “significant” as in game changer without testing between P90 (which I have tested, I found no difference between P90 and M90 in sound quality as well, which I suspected would be the case) and L90.
I’m more interested in the hardware/software as a package, I’m seriously interested in how can help bring out the best in this, but at the moment I don’t even see this helping
(I think their looking at it the wrong way, using motion sensors etc) it has a long way to go, another thing is , I’d like to see this moving quicker as well, miniaturized as well as software, if only they would spend the same research dollars on this as they do for .

In reply to @WhiteHat

@WhiteHat said:

The pictures in the linked web page below show the openings around the outside of the receiver, looks like cheese grater screen that the sound comes into and through the middle of the receiver.

It is actually HF3 filter, it is not easy to remove and put in. Resound started using this filter in the omnia hearing aid with UP receiver mold…

@x475aws said:

objective measurement

Yes, i tested the P90 up against my M90, I no longer use Phonak models after being a long time user of them, Autosence is my biggest bugbear,I had my best experience by Phonak with the early Bolero models.
I now use Signia AX and ReSound Ones as daily drivers, I like to change but this could be the “better the devil you know” type of case!

P.S, I’m not knocking Phonak, they are great for whoever likes them, unfortunately not for me.

@tenkan said:

Autosence is my biggest bugbear,I had my best experience by Phonak with the early Bolero models.

Yes! SoundFlow in my opinion works much better then AutoSense

Edited

Yes of course(including what specifications are offered) this is why I stated my reasons for holding off getting the lumity, if you already have the paradise wait until the next platform, which will most likely offer more meaningful upgrades, but who knows…maybe, we’ll just have to wait and see, we can usually get a heads up on what their working on through different channels, is something Phonak will be playing “catch up” on.

Check out another review here.

Phonak Audeo new P50 vs old Q90 - has the tech really not improved that much?
I wish I could try the Lumity but they’re not available where I live but I’ll try and find out when it will arrive. I think you’re right; I don’t earn as much as I did when I bought the Q90s, but if I can make them last 8 years then the cost over time equation is not too bad.

Just be aware that your a little bit outside the fitting range for Active Vents, so possibly unsuitable.

Screenshot_20221123_181345

Hey unfortunately I’m no longer using Phonak anymore, the problems your experiencing are common issues for severe and profound losses, we are all looking for better speech comprehension especially in noisy environments, don’t let me put you off trialling the Lumity models, hearing is very selective and sensitive to ones own loss and environment,finding the right is a work in progress for most of us I’m afraid, I don’t know if your seeing an audiologist that is working with you to ensure your getting the best out of those paradise versions you have now, pretty much it’s that, before you can go find another brand to trial and or

@tenkan Yes I agree , the hearing aid is only as good as the audiologist programming them. I think I have a good Audi. I’ve been thru several over the years.

In reply to @Sequoia_Woman

@Sequoia_Woman said:

JordanK, I’ve started the process of getting the Phonak Lumity 90s. Do you have those activeVent receivers?

I do not have the ActiveVent receivers. My audiologist thought it might be interesting for me to try them but when we got Phonak on the phone, they indicated that my hearing loss isn’t suitable for ActiveVent and I decided to pass. I will be honest with you. I was hearing so well after the first fitting of the Phonak Lumity L90’s with the normal receivers that I was very reluctant to start messing with anything. One of the new things included with Lumity is a new first fit algorithm. My audiologist started with that and then adjusted based on during the test. Results were amazing.

Jordan

@JordanK said:

but when we got Phonak on the phone, they indicated that my hearing loss isn’t suitable for ActiveVent and I decided to pass. I will be honest with you. I was hearing so well after the first fitting of the Phonak Lumity L90’s with the normal receivers that I was very reluctant to start messing with anything. One of the new things included with Lumity is a new first fit algorithm. My audiologist started with that and then adjusted based on DSL during the REM test. Results were amazing.

What were you wearing before?
Is there anyone who moved from Paradise to Lumity and noticed this difference?

I too can add ActiveVent but no one knows if they’ll be a good fit for me or not :)) Damn, reading this forum with all these cool option makes me have some real FOMO for better audiologist in my area…they don’t even have .

@sickbay said:

What were you wearing before?

I was wearing Resound Quattro 9’s prior. I also tested Lumity vs Resound’s new Omnia and it wasn’t even a contest.

Jordan

In reply to @sickbay

@sickbay said:

I too can add ActiveVent but no one knows if they’ll be a good fit for me or not :))

Your outside the fitting range, but that doesn’t mean you can’t try them ; )

Screenshot_20221123_181345

@sickbay said:

Is there anyone who moved from Paradise to Lumity and noticed this difference?

See here, it’s already been talked about in another post, use the search button from right here on hearingtracker to find out more about this.

Phonak Audeo new P50 vs old Q90 - has the tech really not improved that much?
I wish I could try the Lumity but they’re not available where I live but I’ll try and find out when it will arrive. I think you’re right; I don’t earn as much as I did when I bought the Q90s, but if I can make them last 8 years then the cost over time equation is not too bad.

Related discussions