Resound Omnia vs Phonak Lumity

@SpudGunner: If I may offer my impression… VAC+ is Oticon proprietary fitting formula. I spent a couple of months comparing a VAC+ program to a DSL V.5. I had these two programs in my More 1 as P1 and P2, both with similar gain and the same “automatics” and “moresound intelligence” setup. VAC+ sounded smoother, perhaps. DSL sounded crisp, sharp, perhaps more true to the real input. But, as I mentioned, they had similar gain curves.In the end I was OK with both of them, couldn’t notice a significative edge of one over the other.

However, one thing worth metionting, at leat in my case (with my audiogram), is that their initial target differ considerably. For instance, in my left ear, VAC+ was around 10dB louder in average.

@JordanK said:

The interesting thing is that no other adjustments were necessary after that.

Despite what this forum would lead people to believe, after REM this is common.

@e1405: Thanks for offering your opinion. Of course, it is welcome! The difference you have described marched my first encounter with DSL bs VAC+ to a tee. My second trial has produced results that are almost diametrically opposed to my first impressions. In other words, the DSL sounds much warmer and softer than the VAC+.

Smooth is a good word for VAC+ :that’s the impression that I first got when I was initially comparing it to DSL v.5. So … I’m wondering what has changed.

I’m due to have another hearing test in a few weeks. It will be interesting to see if anything has changed dramatically. Certainly my impressions of these two fitting rationales has changed dramatically, and I’d like to find out why.

But thanks for your answer. I appreciate the time you took to post it, and it is most helpful and welcome as I try to decipher this change.

Happened to me, too. One and done, except for some additional programs like acoustic phone and comfort in echo.

WH

Hello @mstrmac

I did try the Oticon More. I hated them. The sound was amplified, but unnatural and I couldn’t hear some of the everyday sounds that I normally hear. My husband, for example. I NEVER have trouble hearing him. He’s loud by most people’s standards. I couldn’t hear a word he was saying with the Oticons. I kept having to ask him to repeat almost everything he was saying. Very frustrating for both of us.

They also amplified sounds that I DON’T want to hear, like dishes clattering together. So annoying!

This wasn’t the first time I’ve trialed Oticons. I wore a test pair before I got my first pair of Phonaks (Marvels) 3 years ago. The Oticons were horrible. I thought that with the Oticon More they might have gotten better, but they didn’t, but I was willing to give them another chance. I’m sure it’s not the same for everyone, but Oticon just isn’t for me.

Like you, speech in noise understanding was my main goal in getting new hearing aids. The Lumity are outstanding; unlike anything I’ve ever experienced! I was in a noisy bar with my husband and could easily hear him. He, however, kept asking me to repeat myself. He was having trouble hearing what I was saying. I was surprised and had to ask him if it was noisy in the bar, because all I could hear was dull background noise!

I am extremely pleased with my Phonak Lumity. It’s hard to believe how much better they are than the Phonak Marvels they replaced, but they really are amazing!

My advice is to trial as many different aids as your audi will let you. That way you will know which one is best for you, and you can experience the difference between them for yourself. Let me know how it goes!

I love my Oticon More1 aids, but I realize and understand they aren’t for everyone. We are all individuals and have different opinions and hearing needs. My hearing loss is such and my trust in my VA Audiologist is such I would accept what he believes is best for my needs. While I have worn Oticon aids for 13+ years and love the open sound concept, if he said that a different brand of hearing aids would help me understand speech better I would willingly accept that and work to adapt to the aids. If my life has taught me anything it is that I can adapt to what this life throws at me.

@mstrmac I found an email in my inbox right after I sent my last reply. The new Oticon Real might be something to check out. Sounds like it’s Oticon’s new model in response to Phonak Lumity.

New Oticon Real Hearing Aid with Polaris R Chip Platform Improves Clarity and...

Today, Oticon launched its new Oticon Real hearing aid that provides access to the full spectrum of real-world sounds with exceptional detail and clarity while protecting against sudden disruptive sounds so users can stay comfortable and sharp in the...

Not making any blanket statement except that I trust my audiologist to make the right decision for my hearing loss and needs. He has proven to me that he has the knowledge of both the hearing aids and my hearing loss as well as the willingness to listen, ask questions and research. While I am not going to resort to making my own adjustments, my audiologist allows me to set in front of his computer and see all of the details and adjustments available for my aids, to ask questions about them and even ask to try them. He isn’t a control freak like some on here talk about, and I know myself well enough to know I could very well screw my aids over if I attempted to do it by myself.

@SpudGunner said:

DSL sounds softer, less distinct than VAC+

While I don’t know about the VAC formula, I have been playing with different formulae on the Resound and I will include three charts for each of the NAL-NL2, Resound’s own Audiogram+ and DSLv5-Adult

@JordanK said:

DSL v5.0 is sound level target that is used during the REM testing process

I am not 100% sure but I think the DSLv5 is one of the formulae used as a starting point to fitting. I am not sure if there is a criteria based on ones hearing loss that the audi chooses for each individual. I am unsure about it being only for REM. The dotted lines in the graphs I sent are the target lines for the formula and I think you measure the actual value and if there is a deviation from the target (for the formula used), than you play with the gain to bring the curve on top of the target line.
For instance, in the example below, assume the red line is the REM test result. It is several dB lower at the low frequency end. Than you boost the signal until the REM overlaps the dotted line, I think.

@cvkemp: My post was not responding to you, at all, Chuck. It was supposed to respond to @jonifoz . Sorry for the confusion.

@jonifoz: No, I didn’t miss your qualifying statements … Myself, I would have preferred reading about what may have gone wrong in your fitting that made the Oticon devices (which are no better nor worse than any other hearing aid made by the Big 6) perform so badly for you.

I don’t believe there was anything wrong with the fitting. The same audi has fit me with 4 different pairs of hearing aids. Two were Phonak, two were Oticon. Phonak were wonderful; Oticon not so much.

For the record, I have worn hearing aids for almost 30 years and feel I have a lot of experience. I have had Starkey, Resound, Siemens (Signia) 2 pairs, tested Oticon, and have now had 2 pairs of Phonak. I only did what I suggest anyone with hearing loss should do. Try as many aids from different manufacturers as you can.

I’m getting frustrated having to repeat this-- not every manufacturer’s aids work for every person. Oticon may work for you, but not for me. Phonak may work for me, but not for you. I do find it interesting, however, that you accuse me of criticizing Oticon. You assume that if Oticon isn’t working for me it’s because of the fitting, despite the fact that my knowledgeable audi has 40 years of experience and the 2 pairs of Phonaks I’ve been fitted with by this audi have been amazing.

By continuing to criticize Phonak, you are doing the same thing you accuse me of doing.

@jonifoz said:

not every manufacturer’s aids work for every person. Oticon may work for you, but not for me. Phonak may work for me, but not for you.

This is very true.

I’ve gone to Oticon from Phonak as I hear better with Oticon.

My Step Mum went from Signia to Phonak to Oticon and prefers Phonak.

@Zebras Love this! So true! My point exactly!