Phonak Naída Lumity L50-UP vs Naída Paradise P50-UP?

Phonak Lumity Naida 90 UP BTE Review

Here is the title of a very good review of the P and L Naida aids.

My word recognition is better than that of cochlears. I did just have abutments installed for oticon pontos. Gotta wait til feb to turn em on tho. The issue i am having with phonaks and oticon xceed up’s is occlusion effect. They sound great, but theres tremendous pressure in the low frequencies where i need the most power. I’ve tried venting and using the occlusion effect settings in target, but then after its recalibrated i lose the gain i need in the low frequencies. So i guess I’m mostly curious if the new Lumity aides use the same dual prism processors or not. If they do, i suspect the occlusion effect still remains.

When i wear the aides, over a period of a few days the occlusion effect accumulates then my head feels like its gonna pop from all the pressure. I never had this issue with my naída Q series aides. I have tried numerous audi’s, all the same results. Occlusion effect… I’m hoping the pontos are the ticket but I’d still like backup aides since the pontos are medical devices and no private practices deal with them. If a ponto breaks, dealing with a hospital is a headache and likely a long process. Not like a private practice where you can stop in and drop off the hearing aide and get it back within a week.

@anon54276456 said:

The windblock is still thoroughly disappointing compared to Oticon.

Weird how different audiograms compare.

I can’t hear any wind at all with Phonak Naida P70 UP even in gale force winds but I can with Oticon Xceed 1 UP, a lot!

Wind Block is turned to 0 on Phonak.

The phonak will block the wind, at the sacrifice of quality hearing anything else. The oticon won’t sacrifice any quality while eliminating the wind, and feedback for that matter in my experience.

Yeah there the same in most respects, you’ve seen yourself what Phonak does compared to Oticon, waiting for the next true platform release from Phonak would be a better bet, you may have seen the posts from our resident forum members who have fantastic results going from P to L, so it’s really an individual thing if it’s worth it or not, I’ll tell you what, we’re only just touching on dual core processor’s, next we need quad core, a single chip processing for each environment! We might need some breakthrough for battery technology tho…

@anon54276456 said:

Other than the supposed “better clarity” i see no difference in the P vs L

Your not alone in this, the real difference in the beholder.

@anon54276456 said:

But again, i cannot find a spec sheet on whats actually different about the two.

Would of thought that’s easy enough, a good way is through target, as target can open the correct webpages and you could then compare.

Well the audi programmed them, then I will fine tune them afterward. I was finally able to get my P50’s to sound alright after like a year of messing with audi’s and self programming. The thing with audi’s, most of them weren’t even aware of occlusion effect, or that target even had an occlusion effect option, so i found that setting to be helpful when applied on “weak”. It seemed most audi’s weren’t fluent in target in general. They all can put a ln audigram in and obviously produce prescribed settings, but the extent of most i have visited was just adding gains, maybe tweaking soft sounds settings or something like that. Outside of that, havent been able to find much help from audi’s, especially once they get paid, its like their job is over. Half heartedly following up, seemingly unconcerned, their committment entirely changes when they get paid I’ve been hard of hearing 40 years, since birth. Seen many audi’s… my bilateral hearing loss probably isnt helpful. I have enlarged vestibular aqueducts, which push my stapes open, my bone conduction sucks too, significant reverse slope. All the issues I’m having are in the low frequencies with occlusion effect. Like i said, tried venting to no avail too.

Thanks for the explanation.
In all those years of hearing loss have you ever been happy with hearing aids? The reason I ask is the fitter is so very important.

Your comparison of the Naida P and L aids is not really fair for other members to use as data. Your situation is very individual and your self programming has skewed the results to some extent. It’s too bad you haven’t found a good fitter for your hearing loss.

We have a few pros on this forum that will help with programming details if asked nicely.

No, I was hoping you were, wanted to ask questions. But yes I’m very aware its a much different approach. It just seems in general the aides aren’t even designed for reverse slopes anymore, almost like their only target is the traditional slope.

But there are many people, some pros and some expert self fitters, on here that have been tremendously helpful. More so than an local pros. I have yet to meet or find a reverse slope expert tho.

Have you tried programming those aids yourself from scratch? Save the programming the Audi did first. Start a new client and give it a try.
Follow Target to a Tee using in-situ audiogram. Acoustics properly set in Target is critical.
Keep us posted.

Yes, i have. The audiogram direct helps a lot, because theres the rabbit hole of earmolds… i have occluded molds, vented molds (1mm, 1.5mm, 2mm), i even have a pair i forget what thet are called but very long and the tips are not rounded. But then i have to go back and add the bone conduction. Because otherwise the compression is insane without the bone conduction.

Also i have like 25 audiograms from the last 2 years. And they all have varying results. So i’ve tried all those bone conduction results with the audiogram direct results. I have tried all the formulas too… The DSL and APD 2.0 both sound great, just this occlusion effect. So i set the occlusion effect setting on weak, that helps, but then i lose critical frequencies i need…

And I’ve tried the prescribed comp, semi linear and linear fittings. I’ve had best luck with occluded molds, APD 2.0, prescribed compression, put the occlusion effect on weak. I turn the MPO’s down a little. But I’m losing significant gains after i do all that, but its comfortable… i struggle. But my head doesnt feel like its gonna explode from occlusion effect.