Skip to content
HearingTracker
Log in

Apple TV (the device) + Phonak TV Connector

This topic is closed.

20 replies2.6k viewsLast reply

Jump
Link to this topic

The Apple TV device, the way I have mine set up, does not work with the TV Connector.

I’m posting this in case anyone else has tried or is contemplating setting up an Apple TV device with their TV and soundbar/audio system, as I have.

In my case, so that I could take full advantage of my system’s capabilities (which includes Dolby Atmos) I must connect the Apple TV, via. HDMI cable, directly to my Samsung Dolby Atmos Soundbar. I then connect the soundbar, via another HDMI cable, to the TV.

There is no Audio Out feature on my Apple TV device for splitting off or accessing the Audio from the Apple TV.

Of course, there IS an Audio out (Optical Out) at the back of the TV where a Phonak TV Connector can be connected. However, the sound from the Apple TV never makes it to the TV itself (from which the audio could be output via the audio Optical Out and to the TV Connector). The TV is acting as a monitor only, to the Apple TV video signals.

It is possible to “bypass” the Soundbar and, through the TV Settings menu, change the output to the TV Speakers. When doing this I do get audio to my through the Phonak TV Connector. However, the sound bar does not put out any sound and I do not get the benefits of Dolby Atmos, etc. Just the tinny TV speakers put out sound for anyone else in the room.

I also tried using a splitter between the Apple TV HDMI Out to the Soundbar IN to split the audio out and connect that to the TV Connector. The splitter (at least the one I used) could not pass through the Dolby Atmos signal to the soundbar, just 5.1 Dolby Digital. Also, when doing this, the video goes from UHD (Ultra High Definition) to SHD (Standard High Definition) and believe me, you can tell the difference. So that idea was also a bust.

My solution has been to use my newly acquired Phonak Roger Select in listening mode placed on top of the soundbar in the middle of it (it’s about 5 feet long). This works pretty well once balanced. (Note, I am NOT connecting the Select base unit into the TV Audio Out where the TV Connector would normally connect. I am using it in microphone mode, as if in a restaurant.)

This is a little complicated, so I hope I’ve explained it well enough. I spent a lot of time trying to make this work as well as I could and I’m hoping I can save someone else a little time by reporting on my experience.

9 people in this conversation10 min readJump to latest

Do the other people in the room care about audio that much? My spouse doesn’t notice or care. I have some decent speakers and a sub for my ambient listening with the aids (or not) and then I might choose to use the TVC.
Can you post the make and model of the tv and the model of the soundbar and maybe the version of the Apple TV box.
My tv basically acts as the audio center doing 2.1. It’s adequate. All video sources pipe into it via HDMI.

Edited
@z10user2 said:

Can you post the make and model of the tv and the model of the soundbar and maybe the version of the Apple TV box.

TV: Samsung Ultra HD (2160P) Model: QN65Q80RAFXZ A
Soundbar: Samsung HW-Q80R
Apple TV: 2021 Apple TV 4K (32GB) - it has only an HDMI out and a LAN plug and power input.

you can buy a HDMI to HDMI and optical converter adapter. Search for Tendak or similar adapter. It’s 20 bucks on Amazon.

20220717_151859

In reply to @platypus

Have you done all the software/firmware updates to all the devices?
The tv appears to have Apple TV built-in. Is that not an option?
Page 101 of the tv manual seems to talk about output.
Does your TV Connector have buttons on the top?

I’m surprised at your findings that the sound doesn’t make it to the tv. I would think there should be sound at the tv with that HDMI connection.

Can you connect the Apple TV to an HDMI port on the tv and then optical out to the soundbar? Or even HDMI out to the soundbar? It looks like things are all Atmos aware. Then split the optical out to the soundbar and the TVC. Does the tv mention HDMI ARC?

I have a Vizio TV, Apple TV, Bose soundbar and a TiVo dvr. I have the TiVo and Apple TV connected to the TV by HDMI cables, optical audio out from the TV to the soundbar and analog audio out from the TV to a Philips Hearlink TV connector. I have the Vizio speakers turned off. I get the sound to the TV connector just fine from both the TiVo and the Apple TV.

In reply to @z10user2

I see peeps trying to help - thank you! I’m sure there is a hardware combination out there that would produce the outcome I have obtained while also using the TV Connector. My solution, given my particular hardware, is to use the Roger Select as a microphone next to my Soundbar.

The outcome I have is:-

Video: Dolby Vision (or UHD)
Audio: Dolby Atmos
: Roger Select in Microphone mode

This works for me with the devices I have. Balancing the sound of the Select gives both an immersive listening experience (due to Atmos when provided by the source) and clarity of speech via the Select.

For ambient listening, when I had a 5.1 system I finally figured out reducing the satellites to let the center dominate where the dialog is. Some shows these days just have so much background music that it’s not background anymore…the dialog seems to be background. Very irritating. Even the able-hearing spouse struggles with those shows.
I also played around with a loop that was split off the center output.
I don’t use a loop or the 5.1 anymore. Plain old 2.1 and everything centered off the tv. The TVC is great for a little extra while watching with the spouse. And great for when the spouse has gone to bed (in our small place).
I think of these things a bit like a computer network. Everything is centered off the hub (router/switch). In this case my hub is the tv. In your case it’s the soundbar. I would have done it differently.

But hey if you’re happy with what works now then great.

In reply to @platypus

I believe this is what you’d need for UHD and Atmos to be passed through, while providing you an audio tap for the TV Connector:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07BHYXVTY/ref=sspa_dk_detail_0?psc=1&pd_rd_i=B07BHYXVTY&pd_rd_w=v99Yy&content-id=amzn1.sym.999c0877-3704-4f0f-9726-eebf80846a35&pf_rd_p=999c0877-3704-4f0f-9726-eebf80846a35&pf_rd_r=YV1419737NWTE5A110RW&pd_rd_wg=Q5BWR&pd_rd_r=a0db0a8e-7dfc-4c04-b224-0650f140ced4&s=industrial&smid=ALEWIQ2F9CQDR&spLa=ZW5jcnlwdGVkUXVhbGlmaWVyPUExVUUzUzcxOTZGWE85JmVuY3J5cHRlZElkPUEwMDQwODk0RzA0MEFaV0cxRzFDJmVuY3J5cHRlZEFkSWQ9QTAwMjcxOTgyMVJHTFBUNkdIMDc2JndpZGdldE5hbWU9c3BfZGV0YWlsJmFjdGlvbj1jbGlja1JlZGlyZWN0JmRvTm90TG9nQ2xpY2s9dHJ1ZQ==

In reply to @uburoibob

Update: I ordered that device with high hopes. It arrived a couple of days ago. Unfortunately it did not work as advertised - at least not with my setup. Straight out of the box and connecting it directly into the Apple TV then out to my TV/Audio setup, was a complete fail. Either nothing or a spinning wheel then nothing or occasional screen image then nothing. Downgrading Chroma (in the Apple TV setup options) from 4:2:2. To 4:2:0 solved that problem and a stable video was possible, however at the more grainy 4:2:0 level.

However, no setup configuration would pass through Dolby Atmos to the audio system I have. 5.1 DD did pass through and the Optical out did then feed to the TV Connector and Roger Select TV base unit.

But, it couldn’t perform as advertised so I returned the item for a refund. Worth a shot though.

Sorry about that. It seemed as if it would do the trick. If they’d just put a headphone out on anything these days, it would be so much easier.

It’s a complicated issue when it comes to Dolby Atmos and how to sling it around the place.

My Samsung TV will send Atmos to my Samsung Soundbar via eARC. But only when one uses the Internal Samsung Smarts. For some reason known only to Samsung electronics engineers theTV will not accept an Atmos feed from an external source such as an Apple TV smart box and then feed it down to the Soundbar via eARC. That is what most of us do when setting up our TV and sound system. And I tried that too. But no Atmos. I prefer the overall experience and quality of image from the Apple TV versus the Samsung Smart TV front end and the only way that works, to get Atmos to the sound bar and 4K to the TV, is to connect the Apple TV directly to the sound bar and the TV to the Soundbar. ARC still works and the Apple TV controls the TV and the Soundbar using the Apple remote.

Again, my workaround to all this is to use the Roger Select as a microphone placed on top of the Soundbar. It does a reasonable job of sending speech to my .

A better solution would be a splitter that can actually pass through 4K (and Chroma 4:2:2) UHD + Atmos with an Audio Out for the TV Connector. Or even better would be an Audio Out on the Apple TV like they used to have.

I know I’m bumping up an old thread, but I was pleasantly surprised to find that my Phonak aids connect natively to the Apple TV itself - no connector needed. Not sure if this is a recent development. The Apple TV is an older generation too, by the way. 2015 HD. So it must be a software update.

Phonak has old school universal bluetooth connectivity. At the cost of faster battery drain and possible latency between sound from the TV Speakers and what you receive in the hearing aids.

WH

Edited

In reply to @platypus

I want to provide a further update here to my audio setup…

And this would only be of interest to a very few people on the planet, so I apologize in advance if this all sounds way too geeky and irrelevant to most people.

The result is an improved audio experience versus just using the RogerOn to relay audio to my hearing aids as a .

I recently came across the OREI BKA-1 8K HDMI Audio Extractor. This extractor performs as advertised on my system. That is to say, it passes through full Dolby Atmos audio from my Apple TV box to my soundbar and full video in UHD/Chroma 2.2. The optical out also passes through audio.

However, the Phonak TV Connector CANNOT accept a Dolby Atmos (or Vision) signal and it won’t downmix such a signal to Dolby 5.1 or Stereo 2.0.

It is possible to set the DIP Switches on the extractor to 5.1 or 2.0 and this DOES then allow the TV Connector to receive such audio and feed it to my . However, I did find some lag with this arrangement AND of course that means I (or anyone else listening to my media system in the same room) only get 5.1 or 2.0 sound. Believe me, once you’ve experienced the immersive of Dolby Atmos/Vision sound, 5.1 or 2.0 is like Mono versus Stereo - even when listening with HAs.

So, my solution (a compromise) is the following:

  1. I use the RogerOn setup (as I described in my earlier posts) when listening to Dolby Atmos/Vision sound feeds (e.g. many Netflix movies/shows and ALL shows from Apple TV) and …
  2. I use the Phonak TV Connector (connected to the Optical Out of the OREI extractor) for anything that is either Dolby 5.1 or Stereo 2.0 (e.g. ALL feeds from YouTube, most TV shows, Formula One, etc.)

It is a seamless swap over each time. The TV Connector connects to my HAs automatically and the Phonak RogerOn is always on. All I have to do is change my HAs from either the RogerOn or to the TV Connector. This setup allows others in the room to hear full Dolby Atmos/Vision and for the hearing aid wearer to hear it more clearly through the RogerOn microphone as well as sometimes the ambient/immersive sounds. When listening to non-Atmos audio the benefits of the TV Connector are there as well.

Your mileage may vary. Happy to answer any questions if anyone wants to try this or hear if anyone has a better way to do this. Again, I realize this is unlikely to be relevant to most HA wearers out there.

How is 5.1 fed from the extractor to your ? IS there a difference between 5.1 and 2.0? To get the Atmos effect, don;t you have to listen to the speakers directly rather than to sound streamed to the HAs?

WRT Atmos, isn’t the issue that the connection between the TV and the connector is either optical or analog, neither of which support Atmos? IOW, unless a TV connector supports a direct HDMI connection, Atmos won’t work - that means no Atmos with Phonak, ReSound, Oticon…

Related discussions