Skip to content
HearingTracker
Log in

How does the Phonak Sphere AI behave in the cinema?

7 replies283 viewsLast reply

Link to this topic
Reply

I've asked this before, but I've never gotten a clear answer, perhaps because few hearing aid users are movie buffs. Since Phonak implemented the second chip dedicated to separating dialogue from noise, I've always wondered how the algorithm behaves in the cinema: does it treat all the audio in the cinema as if it were noise, allowing you to understand the dialogue but eliminating all the surrounding dynamics? Or does the ​​understand that it's a cinema and therefore doesn't completely mute the entire soundtrack surrounding the dialogue (music, gunshots, explosions, etc.)? I'll need to replace my Phonak P90s soon, and I'm thinking of getting the EONs, but I'd first like to know if I should ask them to create a "cinema" program that disables noise suppression.

7 people in this conversation4 min readJump to latest

I'll defer to any Audi's that want to chime in here, but what I do is use a modified version of the Calm program (which would be similar to the "TV" program that Target often likes to install for us automatically). This locks the into one program and allows ambient sounds in (such as explosions etc. as well as to do the best it can to relay speech from the screen). Otherwise, if using AutoSense, the HAs will bounce around in the sub-programs.

Presumably it will be resolved when is in, but what's the timeframe on that. One might imagine that an individual could actualy advocate with their local cinema to instal it--it's affordable enough that it may be able to be managed at a local level like that.

Film buff here also. I go to a cinema that has world films and most have subtitles since they are not in English. The few movies that they show in English are impossible to hear for me. I have been advocating for subtitles for one showing a week but so far no luck. I would be interested to know how you do with the Spheres. I have Sennheiser now.

I have the I90 Spheres and severe/profound hearing loss. I've been to the cinema once since I got the spheres in January 2025. I cycled through all the programs that I have set up including spheric mode and did not really notice any benefit. I still struggle with dialogue.

The point has been made before, that in recent years, dialogue has actually regressed in movie soundtracks to the point where characters are often mumbling. This seems to be a production design choice.

When I first got my spheres, I had trouble streaming movies because the soundtrack music would overwhelm the dialogue, due to the fact that Auto sense would switch into music streaming rather than speech streaming, when music was present. I had to get my Audi to match the curves for streaming music, to streaming speech, to fix this.

Overall, I will continue to avoid cinema and wait for movies to migrate to streaming platforms, where I can stream the sound and supplement with subtitles. If/when finally makes inroads in theatres and Android + I'll try again.

Really interesting question, and I think the tricky part is that a cinema is the one "noisy environment" where the noise is actually content. In a restaurant the 's job is clear: keep the voice in front of you and push everything else down. In a cinema, the surround music, crowd sounds, and effects are part of what you paid for, so an aggressive speech-from-noise separator has to guess which audio is "dialogue to keep" and which is "everything else to suppress" without knowing the director's intent. No algorithm really does that reliably.

That's why hercus's approach seems most practical to me: lock into a manual program with minimal noise suppression (a Calm/TV-like program) rather than letting AutoSense bounce between sub-programs all evening. If AutoSense classifies the theater as a noisy venue, it will keep engaging the very processing you want disabled, which may explain why cycling through programs didn't seem to help much.

I'd ask the audiologist for a dedicated cinema program that disables the AI denoising and locks the directionality, then try it on a quieter drama first rather than an action film. And CaptainTrips's point about modern mixes burying dialogue is worth factoring in: if the dialogue is mixed low at the source, no hearing aid can recover what is barely there. In that case subtitles or captioning devices will honestly do more for you in that room than any program tweak.

Related discussions