The type of cell used in disposable battery hearing aids doesn’t present the burn risk, just choke.
WH
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
341 replies10.2k viewsLast reply
The type of cell used in disposable battery hearing aids doesn’t present the burn risk, just choke.
WH
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Surely the type of battery chemistry is irrelevant.
It is the electrical discharge caused by saliva contact that does the damage.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Fair catch. Yes, helps me write these.
Not machine translation though. I draft in English with help, which is why it
comes out too smooth. That part is on me. A post like #175 takes me about two
hours that way. Without it I’d manage four sentences and get half the terms
wrong, because I’m on the factory side in China and my English gives out exactly
where the technical part starts.
The claims are mine. Push on any of them.
I’d rather be told it reads wrong than have people quietly decide I’m a bot.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Thanks. I’ll keep going then.
There’s something upthread I think I can settle first. You’re both half
right. cbeissel has the mechanism, it’s the current doing the damage and
not the chemistry burning anything. But chemistry is what sets the voltage,
and that’s where the gap is. The ones that kill children are 3 volt lithium
coins, 20mm across, wide enough to lodge in a small throat and sit there
while the electrolysis works. What I hand out all day is zinc air at 1.4
volts. A size 10 is 5.8mm. A 675 is 11.6mm.
Lower and smaller. Not safe. A small enough child can still lodge one, it’s
still a choking object, and zinc air runs on potassium hydroxide, so a split
cell is caustic on its own. I’d treat any swallowed cell as a same day ER
trip and not wait for symptoms.
What I’d add is where they actually go missing, because it isn’t the fresh
card. Zinc air wants about five minutes open to air before it’s at full
voltage, so you peel the tab and put things down for a bit. The one I find
on the floor afterwards is almost never the new cell. It’s the dead one that
just came out, and I’ve never seen anyone keeping track of that one.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Surely the type of battery chemistry is irrelevant.
It’s relevant. Here’s the administrative rule governing enforcement of the button battery law (Reese’s Law) in the US. The word “zinc” appears 11 times, marking places where the discussion or conclusion differed for hearing aid batteries vs. lithium.
Meanwhile, rechargeable aids contain the more hazardous lithium batteries. A child can’t easily separate the battery from the device, but an animal could ingest the battery by eating the whole thing.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
more hazardous lithium batteries
From what I understand, all batteries contain unpleasant chemicals, but what makes swallowing them a real emergency is that they remain stuck somewhere and start local hydrolysis (due to their electric power, and because our body fluids are all electrolytes). It is this generation of hydroxyl ions (OH-, crazy pH boost) that causes severe local tissue damage- thus, a common risk mechanism for all batteries.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Both are hazardous, but lithium more, because of its 3V vs. 1,45V in Zinc-air. That means after ingestion chemical reaction will be faster and more intensive with lithium batteries.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Zinc air batteries need air, and once swallowed, the source of air is cut off.
So, they are less reactive.They are also smaller than the usual lithium batteries, and less likely to get stuck.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
doesn’t present the burn risk, just choke.
Choke risk would fall under ingestion hazard, wouldn’t it? Here’s an excerpt from the document I posted a couple of hours ago, stating that US CPSC staff advise zinc-air batteries aren’t an ingestion hazard.
I don’t want my spent batteries ending up in my grandkids’ nostrils or ears either when I’m visiting, of course, so I put them in my luggage rather than in a wastebasket. The medications I carry are more dangerous to the kids.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
That’s fair advice, and I’ve honestly tried it both ways. The trouble is my Chinese draft thinks in factory jargon, and the translation lands stiffer than when I fight it out in English from the start. Odd but true. The reading it twice part though, that one I’ll take. Thanks for meeting me halfway instead of writing the whole thing off.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Rechargeable aids have simplified my life. I just put my aids on when I get up and forget about them until bedtime. At night I put them in their charger. If the power goes out the charger has battery backup so there isn’t any worry about them not charging. With Rechargeable aids I haven’t had any issues with sweating moisture. My life is almost like I have my hearing again.
I ‘hear’ what you’re saying
but mine are even simpler than that!
my counter to your simplicity is that I put new batteries in mine on Saturday, and every night at bedtime I put them in a safe place….no concern about getting them in any particular position to engage anything, no concern about power outages or anything else really, just drop them into a box or bowl. Get up the next morning and put them in my ears. The only times they are not in my ears all day long are when I shower or in the rare occasion when I go for a swim. Also off maybe on average once a week for an hour or so while I mow the grass or whatever….
rinse and repeat day after day after day…till the following Saturday morning when I replace the batteries. Powered from around about 5:30AM till 10-11PM pretty much every single day
Once in a blue moon I’ll forget and will get a low battery beep Saturday afternoon or Sunday…in which case it’s no big deal because I have a spare set of cells on my keychain. Less than a minute and I’m good for a solid week!
Oh, and I’ve never had a sweat or moisture problem that I know of. They’re IP68 rated…. but that said I do take them off if I find myself doing something excessively hot/dirty/wet….just because electronic and expensive..…and I would think that I’ll do the same with my new rechargeable aids too in the interest of taking care of them and keeping them just a little less gross.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
It is indeed a true honor to be a “Warbler”
I missed the backstory into this comment. Are you referring to the sound that the aids make when there’s a tone or whistle?
I’d nearly forgotten that a while back there was a long time when I had that in my aids. I’m a habitual whistler…. whistling when I’m doing nothing in particular. It’s how my wife finds me when I’m killing time strolling around a store waiting for her…. Anyway, when I’d whistle my aids would warble on certain tones. That went away at some point, maybe my Audi turned down or turned off my feedback manager!
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Good for you if that is your desire. I don’t worry about power outages either, having my rechargeable aids in a rechargeable charger is the key. I can even go on camping trips. I was raised during a time that electricity, running water and indoor toilets wasn’t available on the farm. Yes I am that old. I learned a very long time ago to take advantage of every luxury I could get. I did my time with disposable batteries and I am so glad that is behind me.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Yes, exactly the TTTF syndrome as it’s sometimes referred to. I’ve heard it referred to as Trilling, as well.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
I missed the backstory into this comment. Are you referring to the sound that the aids make when there’s a tone or whistle?
Yes exactly.
I’m a music lover, and pure tones or musical notes are the enemy of .
I posted long ago on this subject, and occasionally it still comes up.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
I think of the feedback canceller as a line in the gain budget. The receiver leaks back around to the mic. Past a point the loop sings. So I can back the gain off, or I can estimate that leak path and subtract it inside the chip before it ever reaches the amplifier. Estimating buys me headroom I’d otherwise have to go and buy from the fitting itself, and that bill lands on the wearer.
Trouble is my estimator works off how much what’s coming in matches what’s going out. A held whistle matches itself. From the inside it can’t tell your whistle from its own echo, so it adapts toward the wrong thing, gets it wrong, adapts again. That correcting is what you’re hearing. Not the whistle. The word for it in the trade is entrainment, and it’s in the literature under that word too, so it’s worth writing down. Flute, an organ note held down, a smoke alarm, the microwave. Which is why flashb1024’s line about pure tones lands for me. In my experience it isn’t that aids dislike music. A held note fits the description of a squeal that’s already sitting in the firmware we ship.
On yours going away, bradw. I can’t tell you what changed. My guess is something in the kit moved rather than your hearing, though a new mold or a fresh feedback measurement does it too, since that path lives in how the thing couples to your ear. Later designs nudge the outgoing signal so it stops being quite so periodic, and some add a check for whether a tone is really coming back around the fitting or just arriving from the room. Which of those a given aid does, I genuinely don’t know. We get the block and the parameters, not the reasoning. If it comes back, the two worth writing down are which note did it and which program you were in, since a lot of what a fitter can change on the feedback side is held per program.
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
I’m a habitual whistler…. whistling when I’m doing nothing in particular. It’s how my wife finds me when I’m killing time strolling around a store waiting for her….
Very cool.![]()
You’re ignoring this member’s posts.
Log in to reply to this topic.
Hearing Aids2 replies
Bone Conduction Hearing Aids33 replies
Hearing Aid Self-Fitting (DIY)40 replies
Hearing Aids7 replies
Hearing Aids28 replies